Sunday, June 21, 2020

THE WORLD OF SPORTS AND POLITICAL OPINION | SHOULD ATHLETES VOICE THEIR POLITICAL VIEWS?


Design: Niral Patel
Blog written by: Kartik Nair
Note: The views stated by the author are strictly personal.
Before you start reading this write-up as a normal blog which talks about political interference in sporting operations or how political decisions or related factors influence or shape the world of sport, let me ask you to pause for a moment. Stop right there-Don't let your constructed ideas lead you far from what I want to address. Yes, a lot of articles, blogs and write-ups cover issues about how politics influences sports. This one is from a neutral angle, from a different perspective. A different thought point altogether.
The thought process of narrowing the topic to this point has been due on ongoing events of importance, controversies and bold statements made in the professional sporting world, in recent times and in past, and due to few personal experiences to say the least. Well, I've been lucky enough to train under excellent coaches, with exceptional athletes and owing to a few high-level competitions (including national championships) I've played, I've got to directly interact and share my thoughts and ideas with a couple of sports persons representing our nation at the international level. When any decision of importance is taken by a governing body of a particular sport at any given level, it has a direct effect with the players participating in the sport, right from his mental mood to his performance on any given day. The 'decision', if I may call it that way, is relevant, at least to the sportsperson, if not anyone else. But what if that sports person commands influence? Followers? What if that sportsperson is considered a matter of supreme importance in front of their fans and/or followers? What if statements made by them end up influencing you? Or your opinion? Or how you see or perceive things?
I've often heard this, "Yaar, politics ko alag rakhna chahiye sports se." (Dude, Politics should be distanced from Sports). This being said, many would argue about the right of freedom of expression of the very player concerned, that every player, as a citizen of any country has. Sports persons are citizens first and players next, right? And this is not concerning India alone. I'm talking about the global scenario, all of it. Others would take a different stance, though. They would tend to separate sports and politics as if they were North and South Korea. (Even though one tries to make a distinction, there’s no love lost trying to get to each other). That being said, many regard the two as two separate entities. Theoretically speaking, they are two different domains. But in today's world, how valid is that? If you can regard media as a tool of manipulation, then, the figures of influence are not to be left far behind, either. In today's digital age where nothing is hidden from the eyes of ordinary people, it is not uncommon to see professional sports persons (or 'icons' of sport) if you may call them that way, increase their proximity to the political class. Lots of 'candid' images, pictures of luxury goods and photographs shot in luxurious foreign locations seem to increase the life-sized value of the sportsperson. However, more often than not, in today's context, you may also see them with a popular hands-folded gesture (in a popular social sharing app) endorsing and happily promoting the government's policies, stands or schemes for that matter.
To give you a better idea, consider a national team cricketer and an Olympian. Both are people of importance and influence in their own realm (the cricketer, for some reason asserting more authority given our nation in context). The high valued cricketer is dependent in some way on the governing body, the Board of Cricket Control in India (BCCI) whereas the Olympian is entirely dependent on the funding and training programs as decided by the Sports Ministry. The understanding is therefore, simple. Also, sports persons may not be just restricted to sport alone-In the present world, they are influencers. I don't know how ridiculous my next statement may sound to you: Virat Kohli, the captain of the Indian National Cricket Team (Men), has over 64.5 Million followers on Instagram, compared to 3.2 Mn (BJP), 0.74 Mn (INC) and 0.32 Mn (AAP)—mathematically analysing, over 1500 percent more followers than a few political giants in India combined. (Again, this is wrt. a particular app).  Let that sink down. Consider 2020 and the subsequent lockdown caused due to the Corona Virus. In the early days of the lockdown, the Indian Prime Minister (PM) interacted with eminent sports persons of India including the likes of Vishwanathan Anand, Sachin Tendulkar, Virat Kohli, PV Sindhu, Hima Das, PT Usha and Baichung Bhutia among others. A lot of these names have two things in common: Performance and audience reach. The PM thanked them for their performances but spoke of 'an important role' they needed to play to boost the morale of the nation, spreading the message and importance of social distancing.
The very idea of such people raising their voices is, therefore, more critical in the present day. More recently, you might have witnessed the 'kneel-down' movement done by a large number of people, including communities, government officials and the police too, in a large number of places, especially in the US, following the death of George Floyd, a black man who died at the hands of a 'white' police officer. This incident perhaps knocked the first domino in a large arrangement, and we are witnessing a paradigm shift in how people perceive people and cultures. With all due respect to my readers, the kneel-down movement and #ICantBreathe movements are not recent. Although it got wide-scale attention from various celebrities who endorsed it, more recently on social media, actions of various political authorities or campaigns have been time and again condemned by, in this case, professional sports persons. Let me give you a couple of examples where athletes, irrespective of what was to follow or what could've happened to them didn't shy away from making strong political statements at the foot of the authorities. They may or may not have been seen in good light after what they did, but they made their mark. Here are a few I would like to talk about:

The Black Power Salute

Source: washingtonpost.com
 Perhaps regarded as one of the most influential photos in sporting history and one of the most powerful photos of all time in general, the two 200m sprinters, Tommie Smith and John Carlos finished first and third respectively in the 200m final, in the 1968 Mexico City Olympics. Atop the podium and with the American national anthem in background, the duo performed the infamous Black Power Salute, with their heads bowed down and with their hands raised to the sky with a black glove on. To clarify, this was not a style mark. Smith and Carlos protested against the treatment of American blacks and other minorities in the United States. Subsequently, what followed were ostracization from the sporting community, a lot of death threats and harsh criticism.

The #BlackLivesMatter Kneel-Down

Source: vox.com
I do not know if you have heard of Colin Kaepernick, a quarterback who played for the San Fransisco 49ers in the National Football League (NFL). In the 2016 NFL pre-season, Kaepernick began sitting during the national anthem. However, in the final pre-season game, he kneeled when the national anthem was played. This is where it all started. A protest form 'taking a knee' thus became popular and emerged. For him, it was a form of protest for actions done by the police, including the regular murder of black people. It was also in solidarity with the Black Lives Matter movement. He too was heavily criticised (you can maybe still see people burning his fan jerseys). However, a few weeks later, football players (NFL) across various regions followed suit, and a new movement began. It spread to other sports such as baseball, basketball and ice-hockey as well.

Refusal of Army Induction

Source: nytimes.com
This man needs no definition whatsoever. Although he's no more, his very name symbolises what boxing is all about. Muhammed Ali was a professional boxer, the World Heavyweight Champion in 1967. In the same year, the United States was fighting against communist-backed guerrilla forces in Vietnam. The government drafted him to enlist in national service' and fight for his country. In what is still considered a bold move, Ali refused to enlist. He stood opposed to the Vietnam War, opposing the baseless war for power and highlighted issues of power struggle and racism in America. He was arrested and stripped of his title. Although criticisms were hammering in initially, he is fondly remembered today for sticking to his principles, his ideals against the war and for demonstrating leadership for minority causes.

The Munich Massacre

Source: cufi.org.uk
The Olympics is considered the most significant stage of sporting in the world. Representing a nation in an Olympics is regarded as an achievement in itself, irrespective of the results. More than competition among the best in the world, the Olympics is a sign of peace and togetherness, a coming together of various nations. This changed when Black September, a Palestine based terrorist organisation took 11 members of the Israeli team hostage, in the 1972 Munich Olympics, and in an ugly turn of events, made their voice heard by the global community. All hostages were killed in a failed rescue operation and for all those who like reading about intelligence agencies; we all know how hard the Mossad (Israeli Intelligence) clamped down on the Palestinian Authorities and the nation as a whole. All being said and done, this incident changed the geopolitics of nation-states forever.

Again, these are just a few examples. If I were to go on, the quadrennial event in the 'Cold Era' period was a battle for foreign policy between the democratic and communist nations. Countries used it to showcase their stance on political, social and economic issues. In 1936, much before the Cold War, Hitler used the Olympic Games as an image-cleansing tool, as a tool to strengthen the image of the Third Reich and promote Aryan superiority. The United States boycotted the Moscow Olympics in 1980, and the USSR returned the favor four years later at the 1984 Los Angeles Olympics. And it is not just the Olympics. LeBron James, a famous NBA star, wore a t-shirt on which was written "I can't breathe" to express solidarity in the killing of Eric Garner at the hands of a police officer.
In a nutshell, popular sports persons have the power to create a massive impact on the public while making such political statements or statements on socio-political issues. Like the politician, the athlete is bound to generate more interest and attention. If they can take a stand on issues which affect the society in any manner and can connect with the common man, their opinion goes a long way in creating and shaping public opinion. Some may or may not give their views fearing a commercial or public backlash.
You get the gist, don't you? In today's times, the world of technology and social media has changed the way athletes can interact with spectators or fans or even followers. It may only be fair that they use the platform not just to promote themselves as a brand, but also serve larger communities or people by leveraging the power of attention that they can possibly generate. But again, it must be exercised with caution. A shout-out by an influencer can give credibility to a rumour or even a cooked up story. In this internet era, perhaps half the objective is already achieved if this 'influencer gets influenced'. It is then the followers who make it trendy and viral. We can just hope such tools are used by proper people for an adequate purpose. Sports and politics are, therefore, no more separate spheres or identities, in matters of social or political importance.
"If you're going to say what you want to say, you're going to hear what you don't want to hear." - Roberto Bolano
Let me know what you think.
** I would like to listen to your views and opinions on the same. You may click here to give me your views or post them in the comments (Please use your name ‘-xyz’ if you put your viewpoint in the comments section below). The best opinion (or response) received would be featured in my next week’s weekly blog send.
If you like my blogs and would like to make a small contributing for me to keep the good work going, please do consider clicking that little button below. J

Buy Me A Coffee

NOTE: DO NOT COPY ANY CONTENT OF THIS ESSAY/ARTICLE FOR ANY PURPOSE/S WITHOUT THE AUTHOR'S PERMISSION. PEOPLE WILLING TO USE THIS ARTICLE FOR ACADEMIC/RESEARCH PURPOSES NEED TO CITE THE AUTHOR AND THIS WEB PAGE. NOT DOING SO SHALL RESULT IN AN ACT OF PLAGIARISM.

Protected by Copyscape

Subscribe to The Sunday Blog Post :)

* indicates required

1 comment: